"Great!"

These RP smokes are hard to refuse, great cigars..

"It s okay, but ..."

I really wanted to like these, as I m a Maduro guy. But the draw was incredibly hard and it burns slowly, so each cigar lasts forever. That s not necessarily a bad thing, but after a while it became a chore to smoke. Top class construction and burn is razor sharp. Not much smoke output, but the flavours are STRONG - almost to the point of overpowering. If you like super-strong cigars that take forever to smoke usually because of the draw , you ll like this. However, it s just a step too far for me.

"Torpedo - Maduro"

A flavorless, bitter, harsh smoke. I was hoping for some complexity in the smoke there was none. Respectfully, Jim

"Big Disappointment"

I expected a lot more from RP. The draw was tough, the burn was inconsistent and the taste was mediocre. Ashton Maduros are well worth the extra $.

"Yuck!"

Terrible. I am completely disappointed with RP for the first time. Inconsistent draw, horrible burn, raspy, too many plugs with very little smoke. Honestly, if someone offered me one of these I'd say "no thanks".

"Not very good"

I hope it was just a bad stick but... The draw was so tight, I had to "de plug" it. Got a nice amount of smoke from it after that. Burn was great, stick looked and felt very well constructed. Taste was mediocre at best. At about the half way point it began leaving an odd acidic after taste. To the point I felt I needed to cleanse my palate before continuing. I set it down for good right after getting into the last third. Had a horrible aftertaste in my mouth. I will try my other stick.

"Truly Amazing"

A truly amazing cigar. Complex yet very smooth, steady draw, long lasting, great constructing, over all appearance, and consistency. I will be buying this one again with out a doubt.I only have one minor issue and perhaps it was because of the place I purchased it half way through the cigar it began to unravel but I wont hold this against manufacture I believe the retailer is the issue here.

"Solid - Great Maduro Smoke . . ."

Smooth Maduro. Excellent construction, and burn.

"Cigar"

Great Cigar!! Excellent smoke when I can't afford a Padron

"Great Smoke"

I been smoking cigars alittle over a year now, and I tried alot of brands. But, when my masonic brother turn me on to The Edge..... Its been my favorite ever sense.