"One of My Favs"
Daily smoke when I have them. Smooth and burns well.
Kenin Omaha NE October 18, 2022
|
"Great Sticks"
These are absolutely wonderful sticks! I have purchased several boxes of these and will continue to do so. Great construction, great burn and aroma with wonderful tastes throughout the entire stick. If you haven’t tried these yet you don’t know what your missing!!
Markin Illinois June 10, 2019
|
"Great smoke for the price!"
I bought this along with a Davidoff and Ashton to try some higher end cigars and also try the Flor De Las Antillas, as I heard it was very good. After smoking it I d say it s excellent! For what I paid I d buy this again and again. These are great sticks and I like them better than the Ashton for sure and would say it s close to the Davidoff, except the price of the My Father makes it an excellent smoke for a working man s price. Great notes of earth and leather.
S.Rin Southern California October 15, 2018
|
"very good cigar"
smooth smoke all the way
howard hoikein evansvile, indianat April 6, 2018
|
"Shame on the guy from Cincy"
First of all, fellow cigar smokers, don t ruin your teeth, your gums, and your breath by tasting an unlit cigar. This guy needs to find another hobby. Like grazing west Texas prairie grass. Definitely a medium-full smoke but with subtle undertones and, NO, not hay.
BillyBob 6-packin Valdosta, Ga. February 3, 2016
|
"Introduced in LA"
Recently, I flew to LA and had to leave my Cubans at home. Based on Cigar Aficionado s 2012 review and #1 rating I tried these. As a guy who smokes Cubans, it's hard for me to enjoy anything but. However, I liked this cigar so much I bought a box. I am now ordering 3 more boxes from this site. So, without reviewing the taste / burn / etc. I think my actions speak for themselves. Nice cigars!
JOE B. in VANCOUVER, BC November 22, 2014
|
"If your in the mood for cedar."
A little sweet, touch of pepper in the throat, cedar for days. Nice construction, nice burn, attractive band.
Martin in New York April 23, 2014
|
"Great smoke. Especially for the price."
This cigar was amazing. Creamy, fruity, nutty. It just was great from start to finish. Excellent burn. Smooth even draw all the way to the end. You cant go wrong with this smoke especially at its price point.
Anonymous January 1, 2014
|
"Save your money"
My opinion is that these cigars are far from high end smokes. This should be a 4 dollar cigar. I always start by tasting the unlit cigar.
Take a un lit draw and taste the tobacco. A lot of cigars taste like hay, or straw. These taste like straw.
The beginning of the cigar was very harsh, and sour. It had a light draw. When I got to the end of the cigar it mellowed out some. I would give this cigar about a 60. The Partagas 1845 are far better.
I am a one cigar a day smoker. I had sampled many types and from many regions. Its sad that there is a lot of trash out there.
I am also not the type of cigar guy that describes his cigars, as Creamy, or a hint of coffee. My daily smokes, are the 1845s, I have tried many smokes, and this suits my needs, when im not in a country that I can get Cubans. Anyway, happy smoking.
robert in Cincinnati May 1, 2013
|
"Great Cigar and value"
The My Father crew did it again!! What a great cigar. Very smooth draw, great flavors throughout. Not overly complex, but more "just right". The box press was a pleasure to hold. I bought a box of these for a party, and they were a hit.
Tony Mc in Texas April 21, 2013
|